Topic: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Just a crosspost from my newest blog entry. Discuss.

Let me develop my new SPAMAYL plan below.
SPAMAYL, obviously, is an acronym, for ‘Sleep polyphasically as much as you like’.

How does it work?

You nap in blocks of 20 minutes, just like with Uberman. The difference is that you have neither a fixed amount of naps, nor a fixed time for naps. You’re napping, basically, as much and when you like. There’s just one limitation: There needs to be a 20-minutes waking period in between naps. And you need to stand or sit during that period, don’t simply stay in bed/on the couch/at your sleeping place.

After those 20 minutes, you decide if you’re still so tired that you need another nap. If you do, you go back to bed. If you don’t, you stay awake as long as possible, but if you’re back to almost falling asleep again, you go back to bed.

What are the main differences to other polyphasic schedules?

SPAMAYL is not equidistant, and, more importantly, unlike every other schedule it’s not bound to a 24-hour day. It’s pretty unlikely that our body could go exactly 4 or 6 hours with the energy it gets from a 20-30 minute nap, but the 24-hour day limits the time between naps to factors of 24. With SPAMAYL, you could have 4 hours and 37 minutes in between naps, and that might work better than 4:00 or 6:00 hours.

Doesn’t that interfere with my work/life schedule?

That sounds as if it was not realistic. One of the advantages of Uberman/Dymaxion is that you can plan to nap at the same time every day. If you have a school break at 10:25, for example, you can schedule a nap for that time every day. If you napped every 5 hours for example, that wouldn’t be possible.

But with SPAMAYL, you don’t settle for fixed nap times. You could nap, for example, at 0:00, 1:30, 4:10, 5:55, 7:50, 10:25, 17:30, 18:00, 22:20 on a random day. In fact, my theory is that when adapted, a SPAMAYL sleeper would probably settle for 8-9 20 minute naps a day, but concentrated at night- maybe 7 naps at night and 2 during the day. And as everyone here knows, daylight waking time is more valuable than waking time at night.

Your body gets used to pushing naps around, you could get a positive energy budget by taking 10 naps during the night and then none the day afterwards. It doesn’t interfere as much with social life as Uberman and Dymaxion, because, well, if you have to stay awake for 6-7 hours for a social event, you simply do it and nap more before and afterwards.

What about the adaption?
Well, I’m going to try that now, that I have free time for two weeks. The big advantage is that you can, if necessary, sleep 5-6 hours a day during adaption and push the number of naps down over time. In a natural way, because when your body gets more energy from your naps, it will stay awake for longer.
At the same time, you’ll (at least in the beginning) not have as much time as with Uberman, Dymaxion and even E4.
And it’s a *really* weird feeling to sleep for 20 minutes, be awake for 20 minutes, sleep for 20 minutes, lather, rinse, repeat.

Any disadvantages?
One that I can think of: Your naps will probably be not as good as on Uberman or Dymaxion because your body can’t prepare for them as well. You’ll need more naps than on those schedules, even when you’re adapted. But I gladly trade 2-3 extra-naps for strongly increased flexibility and waking-time during the day.

Thumbs up +18 Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

My guess is that when you only stay awake 20 minutes between naps your brain can't separate the two and instead register them as one 40 nap (aka an oversleep), thus making it impossible/harder to adapt. The rule with pavlina-naps is to never take one more/less than 2 hours after/before a "real" nap.
I only vaguely remember this, so I might as well be wrong. But I hope it works, because it sounds interesting! Good luck

"Smokers are also human, but not for so long."
- (Unless they do polyphasic sleeping)

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

I tried something similar, taking a 20 minute nap on the hour every hour all night, in an attempt to get used to never having a full cycle of sleep. You can look on my blog under the label "pentaphasic"; it didn't work out for me.

As much as I would like your system to work, in my experience, naps at times other than the ones I'm adapted to are almost never good naps.

I do agree that it's a weird feeling, though...

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

It would be interesting to see how many naps per day are sustainable. So far, in practice, the only reported success with nap-ony schedules has been with Uberman. But on the other hand, many failed to repeat their success. Maybe most people need more than 6 naps.
And there is no reason to believe that naps should be equidistant. Maybe, naps could be more frequent during the night, when circadian sleep drive is higher, and less frequent during the day.

Potentially, this schedule could start with 12 hours of sleep per day with 32 naps per day. Then you could reduce the naps to the sustainable level

In any case it would be a very valuable experiment. Please let us know of the results of this experiment even if the experiment is not very successful.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

polytrier wrote:

...So far, in practice, the only reported success with nap-ony schedules has been with Uberman...

And Shortyman, who says he's been on Dymaxion for the last ~7 months.

"...people will sleep extra if they can, just like they'll have a second helping of pie if you let them. The existence of a second piece of pie on your plate is hardly an indicator that you're starving!" --PD

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Erayd wrote:

And Shortyman, who says he's been on Dymaxion for the last ~7 months.

Yes, you are right. Sorry, I've missed that one since it is a bit recent.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Rasmus, don't you remain tired all day because your body doesn't know when the next nap will strike? Wouldn't SPAMAYL make you fatigued all day? How do you feel with it?

http://captainmaria.wordpress.com/ Captain Maria\'s Polyphasic Sleep Log -The only polyphasic blog illustrated with comics. Drawn in the early hours of adaptation, so insanity assured.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

I feel pretty good. No, I don't feel tired all day. When I take a nap, I'm absolutely refreshed. And then, after some time, I get tired again. Not too different from any other polyphasic schedule, just that the time isn't the same after each nap.

During the day, a nap might give me enough energy for 6-7 hours, at night maybe just for 90 minutes. But in the meantime I'm feeling really good.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

How is it going now Rasmus and Hatten (and any others who have tried)? To my knowledge your last update was around the start of April. I'm thinking of trying it because my parkourtrainings interfere with my Uberman schedule some days. Do you think it would work to follow Uberman when I can and just do SPAMAYL the days it doesn't work? Do you take a nap just when you're feeling tired or do you have something regular?

"Smokers are also human, but not for so long."
- (Unless they do polyphasic sleeping)

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

I'm still on SPAMAYL, and it works great. I'm taking naps whenever I feel tired and have time to nap, when I already know that I won't have time to nap for a long period of time I also nap when I'm not tired.

It might work, yes. I don't see a problem with getting from Uberman to SPAMAYL. I suspect that you will be a bit tired for 1-2 nap periods when you go back to Uberman, but that shouldn't be a huge problem either. I wouldn't recommend changing back before the night comes because I usually nap more frequently than every four hours during the night, which means that Uberman would be stressful then. Wait until the next morning before readapting to Uberman.

Thumbs up +1 Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

How long have you been on the schedule now? Any suggestions for adaptation beyond the standard ones for Uberman?

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Due to school and stuff I haven't been able to be extremely rigid with my schedule keeping. Just remember to always go to sleep as fast as you're tired during adaption. It doesn't matter if you want to delay it by "just an hour" because that's when a movie ends. It's not worth it.

So no, I'm not adapted, one could say I'm doing everyman with varying core atm =p

I have thought, it must be possible to do everyman like this too?

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

This acronym has been stuck in my head for weeks. I hate you so much. big_smile

-Rick

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Because it's good, bad or just because it's different? ;D

I personally don't like it, I think it should be called "schedule-less" uberman/everyman or uberman/everyman without a schedule. It's nothing more than that, and I don't think it's different enough to have it's own name. Especially not a seven-letter acronym =p
In order to save typing one maybe could say SL-uberman (for schedule-less) or Everyman WAS (without a schedule). What do you guys think?

Does anybody want to try everyman without a schedule? I wonder if one should have a set core or have that moving too.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Everyman WS?

My core is kind of moving at the moment, depending on how busy i am at night. Im TRYING to wake up at the same time every morning.

Id be tempted to move my nap times around being that im having difficulty napping (for the first time ever). Its an interesting concept. Id probably have a set naptime in the afternoon though, or have it flexible.

Im still wondering about the whole "body not ready for REM" thing though.


PS. its an annoying acronym because it got stuck in my head for weeks. wink

-Rick

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Uberman WS sounds like a good one.

I've put the adaption on hold completely, after deciding to sleep 10h before an important test I haven't slept on a nap. But the school ends in just a few weeks, so I will be back. Hopefully with a friend!

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

It's catchy, not annoying  wink
Anyway, I think I'm on this schedule for close to three months now, no complains, no problems.
Hatten is right when he says

Just remember to always go to sleep as fast as you're tired during adaption.

Don't wait until you can't stay awake anymore, when you get drowsy and energyless, go nap.
I think that it is very different from Everyman and Uberman- from Everyman because it obviously doesn't have a core, from Uberman because the naps aren't equidistant and from both because not only do you not have set sleeping times, but you also stop to live by the 24-hour rhythm.

Also, the feeling is not like with Uberman where night and day feel almost the same, because at least I nap a lot more frequently during the night.... so that the night is still the 'staying at home/resting' time and the day the active time.

It's also not free running sleep, because the nap length is set.

So, summarily, the schedule parameters (nap length, nap time, amount of core and naps) are nothing like either Uberman or Everyman or any other schedule currently in use.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

I disagree, the only difference, schedule-wise, between uberman and "spamayl" is that there is no set time for when the naps should be. You say that the amount of naps are different, they don't need to be, it'll probably depend on different people, some might need 6, some 7 or some maybe 5. The nap time doesn't have to be different either, you maybe take most of your naps during the night, but a night-shift worker, or somebody that prefers being up at night instead of at day would maybe have it otherwise. And there may ofcourse be those that, by pure luck, take them almost every 4th hour, just because it fits them.

I think it's possible to integrate a core into "spamayl", one could essentially do anything with it. Obviously it won't be the same as what _you_ have adapted to, but everybody will have a different schedule. One might maybe have several cores, or longer naps, or anything.

"spamayl" is for you:
sleep 20 minutes, and then be awake for at least 20 minutes.
Go to bed when you feel tired.

"spamayl", or the WS clause on any schedule is
sleep x minutes, and then be awake for at least x minutes
go to bed when you feel tired
maybe have x core(s) if one doesn't want to nap as often.



I think being without a schedule opens up a lot of possibilities, that's maybe the way to go to test the most extreme schedules, and gradually adapt to them. eg, in order to adapt to dymaxion (4*30) one have to learn to nap for 30, instead of 20, minutes, which most certainly helps with more naps.




It seems like I've got a friend hooked, we haven't worked out the details, but we'll probably adapt to some sort of spamayl/uberman WS in a few weeks when school have ended.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

im thinking of doing it too. Except an Everyman schedule based on the above "rules". As i mentioned, im having trouble with my set time naps (like my lunch time nap just now).

Something to ponder on the weekend.

-Rick

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

That schedule sounds very tempting to me.

How difficult did you find adaptation to be? It seems like it should be a little easier than Uberman since you can add extra naps that are removed progressively during adaptation.

Did adaptation take more or less time than Uberman (if you've tried it)?

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

note, I haven't adapted, so don't take my words for granted.

I would say that the adaption is easier, but don't slack off, it's still hard, and you need to be on your guard. And remember that you _must_ go to bed as soon as you get the slightest tired, or it will make it way harder.

I would guess the adaption to take roughly the same time, maybe less, but it could probably take a while for the naptimes to "stabilize".

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

For me, it took just a few days (maybe 4-5) to feel functional with the schedule. It took then another 2-3 weeks for the nap times to stabilize, as hatten puts it. In the first few weeks I usually had something like 5 naps on one day and then 10 on the next day- think of it like a car out of control- you steer left, get in danger of leaving the road on the left side, steer right to counter that, and so on and so on- it took a bit of time to get the car moving smoothly in the middle of the road.

I guess that's because when I took 12-14 naps on one day, I felt good enough to go 8-10 hours without a nap on the next day which resulted in almost crashing on day 3, napping a lot on day 4, and so on.
But it stabilized in time, and now I'm taking 7-8 naps a day, except when I have something extraordinarily on schedule- a concert maybe.

The adaption to any polyphasic schedule is hard, but it's much easier than adapting to Uberman. It's ideal when you start on a Thursday evening or so- because then you'll probably be able to go until Friday night without a nap, then you'll pretty much crash during the weekend with times where you'll literally be 20 minutes awake, 20 minutes sleeping for hours- and after that you should already feel pretty good by Monday or Tuesday. You'll sleep more than on Uberman during that period of the adaption- maybe 10 naps a day or so- but eventually you can get down to 7-8 naps a day.

I don't think 6 is possible, because your nap quality won't be 100% as good as on Uberman, so you need a little bit extra sleep to make up for that.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Excellent. Thanks for that summary Rasmus. I'm seriously considering trying it out once the current hectic period at work dies down (I'll be traveling and having to concentrate a lot so its not a good time to shake things up too drastically). That probably means midsummer sometime I'll give it a shot. When I do, I'll try to let everyone know how it goes. If it works, which it seems to for you, this could be the ideal polyphasic schedule.

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

Well, what's the reason that uberman naps are better than [insert name] naps? Is it because you don't have the rigid timing? or that you never is extremely sleep deprived, or is it that one takes too many naps on SL?
I think we should wait with generalizations until we have more people adapted, to avoid fights wink

You discussed german words to put in front of uberman at schodingers blog, wouldn't OZ-uberman (ohne zeitplan) be perfect? xD It sounds awesome, and makes people think we are wizards (from oz) big_smile

Thumbs up Thumbs down

Re: SPAMAYL Plan + Discussion

I think we can generalize informations from what we know about other polyphasic-cycles.
It's most likely because you don't have the rigid timing- Uberman works because the body releases Melatonin every 4 hours. With SPAMAYL/OZ-Uberman/whatever, the body can't anticipate the nap and not prepare for it, so it's a little bit less effective- you need a few minutes to fall asleep.

Thumbs up Thumbs down